Coffee Mill Lake, located in the Caddo National Grasslands of Texas, offers paddlers a 750-acre expanse to explore. The lake features a paved boat ramp for easy access, situated on the north shore within the Coffee Mill Recreation Area. Paddlers should be aware that motorized boats are permitted on the lake, which may affect water conditions.

The lake's shoreline is predominantly natural, with emergent and submerged aquatic vegetation providing habitat for various wildlife. Native plants include water willow, cattail, bulrush, American pondweed, and American lotus. These vegetation areas, along with submerged brush piles near the dam and standing timber in the upper end of the lake, create interesting paddling routes and potential fishing spots.

Water clarity in Coffee Mill Lake is typically stained, with very little fluctuation in water levels. The maximum depth reaches 30 feet, and the lake's surface elevation is 496 feet above mean sea level. Paddlers should note that the use of trotlines, throwlines, and juglines is prohibited on this lake.

For those interested in combining paddling with fishing, the lake supports populations of crappie, catfish, and sunfish. Spring and early summer may offer good opportunities to observe fish spawning activities in shallow areas.

Facilities at the Coffee Mill Recreation Area include picnic spots, campsites for tent camping, and limited RV spaces. A 60-foot floating fishing pier, added in 2019, provides an additional point of interest for paddlers to explore. The recreation area operates on a first-come, first-served basis, and visitors should be prepared for limited parking.

Coffee Mill Lake's historical significance dates back to the 1930s when it was first constructed. The name "Coffee Mill" originates from an early Texas settler who lost his coffee mill on a tree beside the creek, adding a touch of local lore to the paddling experience.